Compare countries

Two or three countries, side by side, one row per question. Pick up to 3.

Countries

IsraelChecked 18 August 2026

Yes, with paperworkWork: HighEnforcement: Active

In one paragraph: Israeli data can go abroad, but never by default. Either the destination country protects data as well as Israel does, or you fit one of eight listed exceptions — usually a contract in which the receiver promises to follow Israeli rules. A big reform started on 14 August 2025 and the regulator now issues real fines. No industry bans exports outright, but several add heavy conditions.
The catch: The general answer is 'yes, with paperwork'. It stops being true in four places. Banks may not put sensitive customer data on a cloud outside Israel unless they have checked the provider meets European-level protection. Insurers and pension bodies must report every offshore outsourcing arrangement to their regulator each year. Identifiable patient data used for research must generally stay inside the hospital or health fund that holds it, not merely inside Israel. And central government has moved its own cloud into Israeli data-centre regions on purpose, so selling cloud to the state effectively requires an Israeli region.
Does this apply to me?: Yes, it can reach a foreign company with no office in Israel — but the law never says so in words. Israeli privacy law simply applies to anyone who collects, uses or processes personal data, with no size or revenue threshold to fall under. There is no general requirement to appoint a local representative. Some organisations must appoint a privacy officer, and that person is allowed to be an outside contractor rather than a staff member.Medium confidence
Can the data leave the country?: Yes, with paperwork — and you must be able to name the route you are using. The default rule is that data may only go to a country whose law protects it at least as well as Israeli law does. If the destination fails that test, you have to fit one of eight listed exceptions, and whichever route you take you also need a written promise from the receiver. No Israeli industry has a flat 'the data stays here' rule, but four sectors bolt extra conditions on top.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?: The model is closest to an allowlist: you may not send data out unless the destination qualifies, and the qualifying list is already populated. It counts if the country signed the Council of Europe data protection convention, or if it receives data from European Union countries on the same terms — so Europe's approved-country list does much of the work. If your destination does not qualify, the usual fallback is a contract in which the receiver promises to meet Israeli standards. Either way you also need a separate written promise from the receiver that it will protect the data and pass it to nobody else.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?: The Privacy Protection Authority, part of the Ministry of Justice, and it is fully operational. It has a serving commissioner, an administrative enforcement department, and it publishes its decisions with names and amounts. In 2026 it fined a national health fund about 256,000 shekels (roughly $72,000) for taking two months to report a security incident, and a small leisure company about 12,000 shekels (roughly $3,400) for a defective privacy notice. Industry regulators — the Bank of Israel, the insurance regulator and the Ministry of Health — enforce their own rules separately.High confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?: There is a clear floor and a clear ceiling, and they sit close together. The floor: security and access-monitoring records must be kept for at least 24 months, and organisations with medium or high security databases must keep a restorable backup of them. The ceiling: if a database contains anything that came from Europe, you must run a mechanism that finds data you no longer need and delete it, and you must delete data on request. Where another law says you must keep something, that wins over the duty to delete.High confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?: There is one main clock and it has no hours attached to it: a severe security incident must be reported to the Privacy Protection Authority immediately, along with what you did about it. 'Immediately' is taken literally — a health fund was fined for a two-month delay. Telling the affected people is not automatic; the Authority decides, after consulting the national cyber agency, and can order you to notify them. Israel has no general law forcing every company to report cyber incidents to the state, so your second clock, if you have one, comes from your industry regulator.High confidence
What's the trap?: Five things that are not in the summary. One: a single record that arrived from Europe drags the whole database into the stricter European rules — since 1 January 2025 those rules apply to any other data sitting in the same database. Two: 'immediately' really means immediately, and there is no safe 72-hour habit to fall back on. Three: fines are calculated per person, not as a flat cap, so a large database turns a small breach into a very large bill. Four: privacy breaches are criminal offences, not just regulatory ones, with prison terms attached. Five: 'data security officer' and 'data protection officer' are two different Israeli roles with different triggers, and having one does not satisfy the other.High confidence
What's about to change?: The big change already happened on 14 August 2025. What is landing now is the detail underneath it. In April 2026 the regulator finalised its binding rules on the contract you must sign before sending data abroad, and separate regulations came into force giving a short grace period — a warning instead of a fine — for brand-new obligations. A guideline applying privacy law to artificial intelligence, including a requirement of consent before scraping the web to train models, is also in play. Watch three switches the government can flip without warning.Medium confidence
Hardest industry wall: Health and social care — חוזרי מנכ"ל משרד הבריאות 1/2018 ו-2/2018 - שימושים משניים במידע בריאות
Government — פרויקט נימבוס - מדיניות הענן הממשלתית

SpainChecked 18 August 2026

Depends on your industryWork: HighEnforcement: Aggressive

In one paragraph: Spain follows the normal European rule: personal data may leave the country once you have the right paperwork in place. But four named categories of data held by the Spanish state must physically stay inside the European Union, and may only travel further to a country Europe has officially approved. Spain's privacy regulator is one of the busiest in the world.
The catch: The relaxed headline stops being true the moment you touch the electoral roll, town-hall population registers, Spanish tax records or data about users of the Spanish national health service. For those four things a standard European transfer contract is not enough and never will be — the law allows only officially approved destinations. Online gambling, telecoms and any system sold to the Spanish public sector carry their own separate rules.
Does this apply to me?: Yes. A company with no office in Spain is still caught if it offers goods or services to people in Spain or watches what they do online. There is no size or revenue threshold to hide under. If you have no base anywhere in Europe you must appoint a written representative inside Europe, and Spain's regulator will happily deal with that representative instead of you.High confidence
Can the data leave the country?: For most businesses, yes, with paperwork — the ordinary European rules apply and nothing in Spanish law says data must sit on Spanish soil. The exception is sharp. If the data is the electoral roll, a town-hall population register, Spanish tax records, or information about users of the Spanish national health service, the computers holding it must be inside the European Union, and that data may only go outside Europe to a country Europe has officially approved. A standard European transfer contract does not work for those four things.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?: The model is an approved-list one, run at European level, not by Spain. You may send data outside Europe if the destination country is on Europe's approved list, or if you sign Europe's standard contract, or if your corporate group has approved internal rules. The list is real and populated. Spain adds one twist: if you want to use a home-made contract instead of the standard one, you must get written permission from the Spanish regulator first.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?: The Spanish Data Protection Agency, and it is very much awake. Its public decision database held 46,925 decisions when we checked on 18 August 2026, with rulings signed as recently as 12 August 2026. Three regional authorities also enforce, covering public bodies in Catalonia, the Basque Country and Andalusia. Spain's artificial intelligence supervisor is now operating too and met the privacy agency in July 2026 to divide up the work.High confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?: Both directions, and they collide. The longest floor is money laundering records: ten years, and the same law then orders you to destroy them. Business books run six years, clinical records at least five years from the end of each course of treatment, phone and internet connection records twelve months, and the taxman can come back four years. In the other direction Spain does something unusual: when someone asks you to delete their data you must not actually delete it, you must lock it away.High confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?: Count three clocks, not one. Everyone has 72 hours to tell the privacy regulator about a personal data breach. Phone and internet providers have only 24 hours under a separate European rule. And if you run something the state treats as an essential service, the cyber clock says report immediately, then send an update within 24 to 48 hours if the incident is critical, or 72 hours if it is very serious, with a final report 20 or 40 days later.High confidence
What's the trap?: Five things that ruin weekends. One: a child can consent at fourteen in Spain, not sixteen, so your global age gate is probably wrong here. Two: 'delete my data' legally means 'lock my data away', so a hard-delete pipeline breaks the law. Three: Spain forces far more organisations to appoint a data protection officer than Europe does, including every school, university, bank, insurer, energy supplier and online gambling operator. Four: misusing someone's personal records is a crime punishable by prison, and companies themselves can be prosecuted. Five: telecoms operators can be ordered to hand over the encryption method they use.High confidence
What's about to change?: The biggest thing is what has not happened. Spain still has not passed the law that brings Europe's new cybersecurity rules into Spanish law, so the old 2018 regime is still what binds — expect that to change and to widen sharply who must report incidents. From 12 January 2027 no cloud provider may charge you to leave or to pull your data out. Watch three switches the government can flip with no consultation: taking over telecoms networks, ordering gambling systems into Spain, and demanding an operator's encryption method.Medium confidence
Hardest industry wall: None found.

The eight framework questions answered for each selected country
Question	IsraelChecked 18 August 2026	SpainChecked 18 August 2026
The three ratings	Yes, with paperwork Work: High Enforcement: Active	Depends on your industry Work: High Enforcement: Aggressive
In one paragraph	Israeli data can go abroad, but never by default. Either the destination country protects data as well as Israel does, or you fit one of eight listed exceptions — usually a contract in which the receiver promises to follow Israeli rules. A big reform started on 14 August 2025 and the regulator now issues real fines. No industry bans exports outright, but several add heavy conditions.	Spain follows the normal European rule: personal data may leave the country once you have the right paperwork in place. But four named categories of data held by the Spanish state must physically stay inside the European Union, and may only travel further to a country Europe has officially approved. Spain's privacy regulator is one of the busiest in the world.
The catch	The general answer is 'yes, with paperwork'. It stops being true in four places. Banks may not put sensitive customer data on a cloud outside Israel unless they have checked the provider meets European-level protection. Insurers and pension bodies must report every offshore outsourcing arrangement to their regulator each year. Identifiable patient data used for research must generally stay inside the hospital or health fund that holds it, not merely inside Israel. And central government has moved its own cloud into Israeli data-centre regions on purpose, so selling cloud to the state effectively requires an Israeli region.	The relaxed headline stops being true the moment you touch the electoral roll, town-hall population registers, Spanish tax records or data about users of the Spanish national health service. For those four things a standard European transfer contract is not enough and never will be — the law allows only officially approved destinations. Online gambling, telecoms and any system sold to the Spanish public sector carry their own separate rules.
Does this apply to me?	Yes, it can reach a foreign company with no office in Israel — but the law never says so in words. Israeli privacy law simply applies to anyone who collects, uses or processes personal data, with no size or revenue threshold to fall under. There is no general requirement to appoint a local representative. Some organisations must appoint a privacy officer, and that person is allowed to be an outside contractor rather than a staff member.Medium confidence	Yes. A company with no office in Spain is still caught if it offers goods or services to people in Spain or watches what they do online. There is no size or revenue threshold to hide under. If you have no base anywhere in Europe you must appoint a written representative inside Europe, and Spain's regulator will happily deal with that representative instead of you.High confidence
Can the data leave the country?	Yes, with paperwork — and you must be able to name the route you are using. The default rule is that data may only go to a country whose law protects it at least as well as Israeli law does. If the destination fails that test, you have to fit one of eight listed exceptions, and whichever route you take you also need a written promise from the receiver. No Israeli industry has a flat 'the data stays here' rule, but four sectors bolt extra conditions on top.High confidence	For most businesses, yes, with paperwork — the ordinary European rules apply and nothing in Spanish law says data must sit on Spanish soil. The exception is sharp. If the data is the electoral roll, a town-hall population register, Spanish tax records, or information about users of the Spanish national health service, the computers holding it must be inside the European Union, and that data may only go outside Europe to a country Europe has officially approved. A standard European transfer contract does not work for those four things.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?	The model is closest to an allowlist: you may not send data out unless the destination qualifies, and the qualifying list is already populated. It counts if the country signed the Council of Europe data protection convention, or if it receives data from European Union countries on the same terms — so Europe's approved-country list does much of the work. If your destination does not qualify, the usual fallback is a contract in which the receiver promises to meet Israeli standards. Either way you also need a separate written promise from the receiver that it will protect the data and pass it to nobody else.High confidence	The model is an approved-list one, run at European level, not by Spain. You may send data outside Europe if the destination country is on Europe's approved list, or if you sign Europe's standard contract, or if your corporate group has approved internal rules. The list is real and populated. Spain adds one twist: if you want to use a home-made contract instead of the standard one, you must get written permission from the Spanish regulator first.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?	The Privacy Protection Authority, part of the Ministry of Justice, and it is fully operational. It has a serving commissioner, an administrative enforcement department, and it publishes its decisions with names and amounts. In 2026 it fined a national health fund about 256,000 shekels (roughly $72,000) for taking two months to report a security incident, and a small leisure company about 12,000 shekels (roughly $3,400) for a defective privacy notice. Industry regulators — the Bank of Israel, the insurance regulator and the Ministry of Health — enforce their own rules separately.High confidence	The Spanish Data Protection Agency, and it is very much awake. Its public decision database held 46,925 decisions when we checked on 18 August 2026, with rulings signed as recently as 12 August 2026. Three regional authorities also enforce, covering public bodies in Catalonia, the Basque Country and Andalusia. Spain's artificial intelligence supervisor is now operating too and met the privacy agency in July 2026 to divide up the work.High confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?	There is a clear floor and a clear ceiling, and they sit close together. The floor: security and access-monitoring records must be kept for at least 24 months, and organisations with medium or high security databases must keep a restorable backup of them. The ceiling: if a database contains anything that came from Europe, you must run a mechanism that finds data you no longer need and delete it, and you must delete data on request. Where another law says you must keep something, that wins over the duty to delete.High confidence	Both directions, and they collide. The longest floor is money laundering records: ten years, and the same law then orders you to destroy them. Business books run six years, clinical records at least five years from the end of each course of treatment, phone and internet connection records twelve months, and the taxman can come back four years. In the other direction Spain does something unusual: when someone asks you to delete their data you must not actually delete it, you must lock it away.High confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?	There is one main clock and it has no hours attached to it: a severe security incident must be reported to the Privacy Protection Authority immediately, along with what you did about it. 'Immediately' is taken literally — a health fund was fined for a two-month delay. Telling the affected people is not automatic; the Authority decides, after consulting the national cyber agency, and can order you to notify them. Israel has no general law forcing every company to report cyber incidents to the state, so your second clock, if you have one, comes from your industry regulator.High confidence	Count three clocks, not one. Everyone has 72 hours to tell the privacy regulator about a personal data breach. Phone and internet providers have only 24 hours under a separate European rule. And if you run something the state treats as an essential service, the cyber clock says report immediately, then send an update within 24 to 48 hours if the incident is critical, or 72 hours if it is very serious, with a final report 20 or 40 days later.High confidence
What's the trap?	Five things that are not in the summary. One: a single record that arrived from Europe drags the whole database into the stricter European rules — since 1 January 2025 those rules apply to any other data sitting in the same database. Two: 'immediately' really means immediately, and there is no safe 72-hour habit to fall back on. Three: fines are calculated per person, not as a flat cap, so a large database turns a small breach into a very large bill. Four: privacy breaches are criminal offences, not just regulatory ones, with prison terms attached. Five: 'data security officer' and 'data protection officer' are two different Israeli roles with different triggers, and having one does not satisfy the other.High confidence	Five things that ruin weekends. One: a child can consent at fourteen in Spain, not sixteen, so your global age gate is probably wrong here. Two: 'delete my data' legally means 'lock my data away', so a hard-delete pipeline breaks the law. Three: Spain forces far more organisations to appoint a data protection officer than Europe does, including every school, university, bank, insurer, energy supplier and online gambling operator. Four: misusing someone's personal records is a crime punishable by prison, and companies themselves can be prosecuted. Five: telecoms operators can be ordered to hand over the encryption method they use.High confidence
What's about to change?	The big change already happened on 14 August 2025. What is landing now is the detail underneath it. In April 2026 the regulator finalised its binding rules on the contract you must sign before sending data abroad, and separate regulations came into force giving a short grace period — a warning instead of a fine — for brand-new obligations. A guideline applying privacy law to artificial intelligence, including a requirement of consent before scraping the web to train models, is also in play. Watch three switches the government can flip without warning.Medium confidence	The biggest thing is what has not happened. Spain still has not passed the law that brings Europe's new cybersecurity rules into Spanish law, so the old 2018 regime is still what binds — expect that to change and to widen sharply who must report incidents. From 12 January 2027 no cloud provider may charge you to leave or to pull your data out. Watch three switches the government can flip with no consultation: taking over telecoms networks, ordering gambling systems into Spain, and demanding an operator's encryption method.Medium confidence
Hardest industry wall	Health and social care — חוזרי מנכ"ל משרד הבריאות 1/2018 ו-2/2018 - שימושים משניים במידע בריאות Government — פרויקט נימבוס - מדיניות הענן הממשלתית	None found.