Compare countries

Two or three countries, side by side, one row per question. Pick up to 3.

Countries

Hong Kong SARChecked 18 August 2026

Depends on your industryWork: MediumEnforcement: Active

In one paragraph: Hong Kong's privacy law contains a cross-border transfer ban that has never been switched on. It was written in 1995 and, thirty years later, still has no start date. So under the general law you can send personal data anywhere with no paperwork at all. The privacy regulator is busy and prosecutes people, but it cannot fine you directly.
The catch: The free-for-all stops at three doors. Licensed securities and futures firms need written permission from the markets regulator before their records live only on servers outside Hong Kong. Government departments are told not to put sensitive or personal information on public cloud at all. And data coming the other way, from mainland China into Hong Kong, is tightly controlled by mainland law, not by Hong Kong law - that is the wall most companies actually hit.
Does this apply to me?: Yes, it can reach you with no office in Hong Kong. The privacy law bites on whoever controls the collection, holding, use or processing of personal data in or from Hong Kong, so a foreign company running a Hong Kong-facing service is caught. There is no revenue or headcount threshold to fall below, no register to join, and no requirement to appoint a local representative. The anti-doxxing powers go further still: the regulator can order an overseas platform to take material down.High confidence
Can the data leave the country?: Under the general privacy law, yes - freely, with nothing to sign. The one section that would have restricted transfers abroad was written into the law in 1995 and has never been brought into operation, so today there is no legal control on personal data leaving Hong Kong. Industry rules are where the real limits sit, and there are fewer of them than people expect: the securities regulator is the main one, and government departments have their own restriction.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?: Nothing. There is no approval to seek, no standard contract to sign and no government list to check before personal data leaves Hong Kong. The model on paper is an allowlist - the regulator would publish a list of approved destinations - but because the section was never switched on, that list has never been issued and is empty. The regulator does publish a voluntary guide and encourages firms to build the safeguards now, but that is advice, not law.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?: The Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data, and it is genuinely busy. By the end of December 2025 it had issued 2,104 orders to 57 online platforms to take down 33,743 doxxing messages, opened 519 criminal investigations and arrested 81 people. But there is a catch that changes the risk picture completely: the Commissioner cannot impose a fine for breaking the privacy principles. It serves a notice telling you to fix the problem, and only ignoring that notice is a crime.High confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?: There is a hard ceiling and almost no floor in the privacy law itself. You must erase personal data once it is no longer needed for the purpose you collected it for, and failing to do so is a criminal offence carrying a fine of up to HK$10,000 (about $1,300). The privacy law sets no minimum keeping periods; those come from tax, company and anti-money-laundering law instead. Where the two pull against each other, the specific keeping duty in the other law wins, and you delete once it expires.Medium confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?: For a normal data breach there is no deadline, because there is no duty. Telling the Privacy Commissioner about a breach is voluntary in Hong Kong - the regulator asks you to do it as good practice and gives you a form, but no law compels it. That is unusual and it is changing: since 1 January 2026 operators of designated critical infrastructure must report computer-system security incidents, so those firms now have a real clock while everyone else has none.High confidence
What's the trap?: Five things that catch people out. First, marketing mistakes are crimes here, not fines - using someone's data for direct marketing without the right consent can mean five years in prison. Second, the regulator cannot fine you, so people assume the risk is low and miss the criminal exposure entirely. Third, Hong Kong sets no age at which a child can consent, so there is no simple number to code into a sign-up flow. Fourth, licensed securities firms need written permission before their records live only on overseas servers, and two named people who live in Hong Kong must be able to unlock them. Fifth, the dormant transfer section, if ever switched on, would also catch data moving between two foreign countries when a Hong Kong company controls it.Medium confidence
What's about to change?: Nothing is scheduled to land in the next twelve months that we could confirm. The critical infrastructure security law already started on 1 January 2026, and the government's guideline for generative artificial intelligence was revised in December 2025. The thing to watch is not a new bill. It is a switch the government has held for thirty years: the cross-border transfer section can be brought into force by a simple commencement notice, with no consultation and no new vote.Medium confidence
Hardest industry wall: None found.

IrelandChecked 18 August 2026

Depends on your industryWork: HighEnforcement: Aggressive

In one paragraph: Ireland follows Europe's rules, so personal data can leave the country once you have the right paperwork in place. But a handful of Irish laws force certain records to be kept physically in Ireland, and breaking those is a crime rather than a fine. Ireland's privacy regulator is one of the toughest in Europe: in 2025 it fined TikTok 530 million euro and ordered it to stop sending data to China.
The catch: The relaxed headline stops being true in four places. Trust and company service providers, and cheque-cashing firms, must keep their anti-money-laundering records at premises inside Ireland for six years, and failing to do so is a criminal offence carrying up to five years in prison. Every Irish company must keep accounting information and returns at a place in Ireland even when the books themselves sit on a foreign server. Health records and telephone and internet connection records each have their own separate rules on top.
Does this apply to me?: Yes. Ireland's data protection law reaches a company with no office in Ireland whenever it offers goods or services to people in Europe or watches what they do online. There is no revenue or headcount threshold to duck under. A company based outside Europe normally has to name a representative inside Europe who regulators and members of the public can write to.High confidence
Can the data leave the country?: In general, yes, with paperwork. Ireland does not have a general rule saying personal data must stay in the country. Sending it outside Europe is allowed once you use one of the approved legal routes. But several Irish laws quietly demand that particular records sit on Irish soil, and those override the friendly headline.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?: Ireland uses the European model. A destination outside Europe is off limits unless it is on the European Commission's approved list, or you put an approved safeguard in place first. The approved list is real and populated: it currently covers seventeen destinations, including the United Kingdom, Japan, South Korea, Switzerland and Brazil. The United States counts only for companies that have signed up to the European Union to United States Data Privacy Framework.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?: The Data Protection Commission, and it is very much awake. It has three commissioners in post — Des Hogan as chairperson, Dale Sunderland and Niamh Sweeney — and it published its 2025 annual report on 30 June 2026. In 2025 it finished four large inquiries and imposed fines of just over 530 million euro (about 580 million US dollars), almost all of it on TikTok, which it also ordered to stop sending European user data to China.High confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?: Both directions apply, and Ireland's floors are longer than most people expect. Anti-money-laundering customer records must be kept for at least five years. Company accounting records and returns must be kept for at least six years. Trust and company service providers and cheque-cashing firms must keep their records for six years and keep them in Ireland. Telephone and internet providers must keep subscriber details for one year.High confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?: Count three clocks, not one. You have 72 hours to tell the Data Protection Commission about a personal data breach that puts people at risk, and you must tell the affected people without delay if the risk is high. Telephone and internet providers report through a separate channel under separate rules. And if the police send you an order to take down terrorist content, you have one hour.High confidence
What's the trap?: Five things that cost people their weekend. First, Ireland's famous ban on advertising to children has never actually switched on. Second, the official copy of the law on the government's own statute website can be out of date and misleading. Third, a child in Ireland is anyone under 16 for consent purposes, not 13. Fourth, some record-keeping failures are crimes, not fines. Fifth, the regulator can only fine a public body up to 1 million euro (about 1.1 million US dollars), so it uses stop orders instead.High confidence
What's about to change?: Three things land in the next year. Ireland's new health records law is switching on in stages, and the parts that let doctors share your file and that allow sharing with countries outside Europe are still switched off. Europe's cloud switching rules make all data exit fees zero on 12 January 2027. And Ireland still has not written the European cybersecurity directive into Irish law, almost two years past the deadline.High confidence
Hardest industry wall: Finance — Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010, section 106
Payments — Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010, section 108I
All industries — Companies Act 2014, sections 283 and 285

The eight framework questions answered for each selected country
Question	Hong Kong SARChecked 18 August 2026	IrelandChecked 18 August 2026
The three ratings	Depends on your industry Work: Medium Enforcement: Active	Depends on your industry Work: High Enforcement: Aggressive
In one paragraph	Hong Kong's privacy law contains a cross-border transfer ban that has never been switched on. It was written in 1995 and, thirty years later, still has no start date. So under the general law you can send personal data anywhere with no paperwork at all. The privacy regulator is busy and prosecutes people, but it cannot fine you directly.	Ireland follows Europe's rules, so personal data can leave the country once you have the right paperwork in place. But a handful of Irish laws force certain records to be kept physically in Ireland, and breaking those is a crime rather than a fine. Ireland's privacy regulator is one of the toughest in Europe: in 2025 it fined TikTok 530 million euro and ordered it to stop sending data to China.
The catch	The free-for-all stops at three doors. Licensed securities and futures firms need written permission from the markets regulator before their records live only on servers outside Hong Kong. Government departments are told not to put sensitive or personal information on public cloud at all. And data coming the other way, from mainland China into Hong Kong, is tightly controlled by mainland law, not by Hong Kong law - that is the wall most companies actually hit.	The relaxed headline stops being true in four places. Trust and company service providers, and cheque-cashing firms, must keep their anti-money-laundering records at premises inside Ireland for six years, and failing to do so is a criminal offence carrying up to five years in prison. Every Irish company must keep accounting information and returns at a place in Ireland even when the books themselves sit on a foreign server. Health records and telephone and internet connection records each have their own separate rules on top.
Does this apply to me?	Yes, it can reach you with no office in Hong Kong. The privacy law bites on whoever controls the collection, holding, use or processing of personal data in or from Hong Kong, so a foreign company running a Hong Kong-facing service is caught. There is no revenue or headcount threshold to fall below, no register to join, and no requirement to appoint a local representative. The anti-doxxing powers go further still: the regulator can order an overseas platform to take material down.High confidence	Yes. Ireland's data protection law reaches a company with no office in Ireland whenever it offers goods or services to people in Europe or watches what they do online. There is no revenue or headcount threshold to duck under. A company based outside Europe normally has to name a representative inside Europe who regulators and members of the public can write to.High confidence
Can the data leave the country?	Under the general privacy law, yes - freely, with nothing to sign. The one section that would have restricted transfers abroad was written into the law in 1995 and has never been brought into operation, so today there is no legal control on personal data leaving Hong Kong. Industry rules are where the real limits sit, and there are fewer of them than people expect: the securities regulator is the main one, and government departments have their own restriction.High confidence	In general, yes, with paperwork. Ireland does not have a general rule saying personal data must stay in the country. Sending it outside Europe is allowed once you use one of the approved legal routes. But several Irish laws quietly demand that particular records sit on Irish soil, and those override the friendly headline.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?	Nothing. There is no approval to seek, no standard contract to sign and no government list to check before personal data leaves Hong Kong. The model on paper is an allowlist - the regulator would publish a list of approved destinations - but because the section was never switched on, that list has never been issued and is empty. The regulator does publish a voluntary guide and encourages firms to build the safeguards now, but that is advice, not law.High confidence	Ireland uses the European model. A destination outside Europe is off limits unless it is on the European Commission's approved list, or you put an approved safeguard in place first. The approved list is real and populated: it currently covers seventeen destinations, including the United Kingdom, Japan, South Korea, Switzerland and Brazil. The United States counts only for companies that have signed up to the European Union to United States Data Privacy Framework.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?	The Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data, and it is genuinely busy. By the end of December 2025 it had issued 2,104 orders to 57 online platforms to take down 33,743 doxxing messages, opened 519 criminal investigations and arrested 81 people. But there is a catch that changes the risk picture completely: the Commissioner cannot impose a fine for breaking the privacy principles. It serves a notice telling you to fix the problem, and only ignoring that notice is a crime.High confidence	The Data Protection Commission, and it is very much awake. It has three commissioners in post — Des Hogan as chairperson, Dale Sunderland and Niamh Sweeney — and it published its 2025 annual report on 30 June 2026. In 2025 it finished four large inquiries and imposed fines of just over 530 million euro (about 580 million US dollars), almost all of it on TikTok, which it also ordered to stop sending European user data to China.High confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?	There is a hard ceiling and almost no floor in the privacy law itself. You must erase personal data once it is no longer needed for the purpose you collected it for, and failing to do so is a criminal offence carrying a fine of up to HK$10,000 (about $1,300). The privacy law sets no minimum keeping periods; those come from tax, company and anti-money-laundering law instead. Where the two pull against each other, the specific keeping duty in the other law wins, and you delete once it expires.Medium confidence	Both directions apply, and Ireland's floors are longer than most people expect. Anti-money-laundering customer records must be kept for at least five years. Company accounting records and returns must be kept for at least six years. Trust and company service providers and cheque-cashing firms must keep their records for six years and keep them in Ireland. Telephone and internet providers must keep subscriber details for one year.High confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?	For a normal data breach there is no deadline, because there is no duty. Telling the Privacy Commissioner about a breach is voluntary in Hong Kong - the regulator asks you to do it as good practice and gives you a form, but no law compels it. That is unusual and it is changing: since 1 January 2026 operators of designated critical infrastructure must report computer-system security incidents, so those firms now have a real clock while everyone else has none.High confidence	Count three clocks, not one. You have 72 hours to tell the Data Protection Commission about a personal data breach that puts people at risk, and you must tell the affected people without delay if the risk is high. Telephone and internet providers report through a separate channel under separate rules. And if the police send you an order to take down terrorist content, you have one hour.High confidence
What's the trap?	Five things that catch people out. First, marketing mistakes are crimes here, not fines - using someone's data for direct marketing without the right consent can mean five years in prison. Second, the regulator cannot fine you, so people assume the risk is low and miss the criminal exposure entirely. Third, Hong Kong sets no age at which a child can consent, so there is no simple number to code into a sign-up flow. Fourth, licensed securities firms need written permission before their records live only on overseas servers, and two named people who live in Hong Kong must be able to unlock them. Fifth, the dormant transfer section, if ever switched on, would also catch data moving between two foreign countries when a Hong Kong company controls it.Medium confidence	Five things that cost people their weekend. First, Ireland's famous ban on advertising to children has never actually switched on. Second, the official copy of the law on the government's own statute website can be out of date and misleading. Third, a child in Ireland is anyone under 16 for consent purposes, not 13. Fourth, some record-keeping failures are crimes, not fines. Fifth, the regulator can only fine a public body up to 1 million euro (about 1.1 million US dollars), so it uses stop orders instead.High confidence
What's about to change?	Nothing is scheduled to land in the next twelve months that we could confirm. The critical infrastructure security law already started on 1 January 2026, and the government's guideline for generative artificial intelligence was revised in December 2025. The thing to watch is not a new bill. It is a switch the government has held for thirty years: the cross-border transfer section can be brought into force by a simple commencement notice, with no consultation and no new vote.Medium confidence	Three things land in the next year. Ireland's new health records law is switching on in stages, and the parts that let doctors share your file and that allow sharing with countries outside Europe are still switched off. Europe's cloud switching rules make all data exit fees zero on 12 January 2027. And Ireland still has not written the European cybersecurity directive into Irish law, almost two years past the deadline.High confidence
Hardest industry wall	None found.	Finance — Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010, section 106 Payments — Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010, section 108I All industries — Companies Act 2014, sections 283 and 285