Compare countries

Two or three countries, side by side, one row per question. Pick up to 3.

Countries

SpainChecked 18 August 2026

Depends on your industryWork: HighEnforcement: Aggressive

In one paragraph: Spain follows the normal European rule: personal data may leave the country once you have the right paperwork in place. But four named categories of data held by the Spanish state must physically stay inside the European Union, and may only travel further to a country Europe has officially approved. Spain's privacy regulator is one of the busiest in the world.
The catch: The relaxed headline stops being true the moment you touch the electoral roll, town-hall population registers, Spanish tax records or data about users of the Spanish national health service. For those four things a standard European transfer contract is not enough and never will be — the law allows only officially approved destinations. Online gambling, telecoms and any system sold to the Spanish public sector carry their own separate rules.
Does this apply to me?: Yes. A company with no office in Spain is still caught if it offers goods or services to people in Spain or watches what they do online. There is no size or revenue threshold to hide under. If you have no base anywhere in Europe you must appoint a written representative inside Europe, and Spain's regulator will happily deal with that representative instead of you.High confidence
Can the data leave the country?: For most businesses, yes, with paperwork — the ordinary European rules apply and nothing in Spanish law says data must sit on Spanish soil. The exception is sharp. If the data is the electoral roll, a town-hall population register, Spanish tax records, or information about users of the Spanish national health service, the computers holding it must be inside the European Union, and that data may only go outside Europe to a country Europe has officially approved. A standard European transfer contract does not work for those four things.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?: The model is an approved-list one, run at European level, not by Spain. You may send data outside Europe if the destination country is on Europe's approved list, or if you sign Europe's standard contract, or if your corporate group has approved internal rules. The list is real and populated. Spain adds one twist: if you want to use a home-made contract instead of the standard one, you must get written permission from the Spanish regulator first.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?: The Spanish Data Protection Agency, and it is very much awake. Its public decision database held 46,925 decisions when we checked on 18 August 2026, with rulings signed as recently as 12 August 2026. Three regional authorities also enforce, covering public bodies in Catalonia, the Basque Country and Andalusia. Spain's artificial intelligence supervisor is now operating too and met the privacy agency in July 2026 to divide up the work.High confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?: Both directions, and they collide. The longest floor is money laundering records: ten years, and the same law then orders you to destroy them. Business books run six years, clinical records at least five years from the end of each course of treatment, phone and internet connection records twelve months, and the taxman can come back four years. In the other direction Spain does something unusual: when someone asks you to delete their data you must not actually delete it, you must lock it away.High confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?: Count three clocks, not one. Everyone has 72 hours to tell the privacy regulator about a personal data breach. Phone and internet providers have only 24 hours under a separate European rule. And if you run something the state treats as an essential service, the cyber clock says report immediately, then send an update within 24 to 48 hours if the incident is critical, or 72 hours if it is very serious, with a final report 20 or 40 days later.High confidence
What's the trap?: Five things that ruin weekends. One: a child can consent at fourteen in Spain, not sixteen, so your global age gate is probably wrong here. Two: 'delete my data' legally means 'lock my data away', so a hard-delete pipeline breaks the law. Three: Spain forces far more organisations to appoint a data protection officer than Europe does, including every school, university, bank, insurer, energy supplier and online gambling operator. Four: misusing someone's personal records is a crime punishable by prison, and companies themselves can be prosecuted. Five: telecoms operators can be ordered to hand over the encryption method they use.High confidence
What's about to change?: The biggest thing is what has not happened. Spain still has not passed the law that brings Europe's new cybersecurity rules into Spanish law, so the old 2018 regime is still what binds — expect that to change and to widen sharply who must report incidents. From 12 January 2027 no cloud provider may charge you to leave or to pull your data out. Watch three switches the government can flip with no consultation: taking over telecoms networks, ordering gambling systems into Spain, and demanding an operator's encryption method.Medium confidence
Hardest industry wall: None found.

BulgariaChecked 18 August 2026

Depends on your industryWork: MediumEnforcement: Active

In one paragraph: Bulgaria is an ordinary European Union country for data. Personal data can leave, as long as you use one of the standard European transfer tools. There is no general rule forcing data to stay in Bulgaria. But online gambling is a hard exception: a control server must physically sit on Bulgarian soil. Bulgaria switched to the euro on 1 January 2026, so all fines are now in euro.
The catch: The relaxed headline stops being true in two places. First, online gambling: an operator licensed in Bulgaria must keep a control local server on Bulgarian territory and stream live game data to the tax authority's server. Second, telecoms: operators must build and pay for interception equipment wired into two Bulgarian state agencies, which cannot be run from abroad. Mapping and aerial survey work also needs clearance from five Bulgarian ministries and agencies before you may even collect the data.
Does this apply to me?: Yes, it can reach you with no office in Bulgaria. The European Union's privacy rulebook applies to anyone who offers goods or services to people in Europe or watches what they do online. Bulgaria's own Personal Data Protection Act sits on top of that and adds extra local duties. There is no revenue or headcount threshold, and no Bulgaria-specific representative: the European-wide requirement to name a representative in Europe is the only one, and it can be in any European country.High confidence
Can the data leave the country?: In general, yes. Bulgaria has no law telling ordinary businesses to keep personal data inside the country. Data moves freely to the rest of Europe, to Switzerland, and to countries Europe has approved; anywhere else needs a standard contract or a similar tool. Two industries break that pattern. Online gambling operators must keep a control server physically in Bulgaria. Telecoms operators must build interception equipment that plugs into Bulgarian state agencies, which cannot sit abroad.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?: Bulgaria uses Europe's system, not its own. There is no Bulgarian list of banned countries and no Bulgarian permit to apply for. If the destination is inside Europe, the wider European Economic Area or Switzerland, nothing extra is needed. Otherwise you need either an official European approval of that country, or the standard European contract, or approved group-wide rules. One Bulgarian twist: Bulgarian law explicitly puts Switzerland on the same footing as a European Union country.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?: The Commission for Personal Data Protection is the main regulator. It is real, staffed and it does issue formal decisions, including ones published across Europe. But it is not a heavy hitter. In a Europe-wide check on deletion rights reported in February 2026, it contacted twenty-three organisations, opened no formal investigations, imposed no penalties, and said it did not plan to. A separate inspectorate polices the courts and prosecutors. Cybersecurity has its own separate regulators.Medium confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?: Bulgaria has strong minimum-keeping rules and a few sharp delete-by rules. You must keep payroll records for fifty years, accounting books and financial statements for ten years, and other accounting papers for three years. Telecoms firms keep connection records for six months. Going the other way, job applicants' data must be deleted within six months unless they agree otherwise, and data you were given with no legal basis must be returned or destroyed within one month.High confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?: There are at least three clocks and they do not agree. A personal data breach must reach the privacy regulator within seventy-two hours. Under the cybersecurity law rewritten in February 2026, an early warning must reach the response team within twenty-four hours and a fuller report within seventy-two hours. Trust service providers get twenty-four hours for that fuller report. Financial firms answer to the separate European financial-resilience rules on top.High confidence
What's the trap?: Five things bite people in Bulgaria. You may not photocopy someone's identity card, driving licence or residence permit unless a law lets you. Children need a parent's consent up to age fourteen, not sixteen. Job applicant files must go within six months. Your accounting software must be able to output in Bulgarian. And one clause of the privacy law was struck down by the Constitutional Court in 2019 but is still printed in the statute.High confidence
What's about to change?: Two dated changes are already fixed. From 12 January 2027 every cloud provider must let customers move their data out for free. Bulgaria's new cybersecurity duties started on 13 February 2026 and enforcement is only now warming up. The biggest live risk is not Bulgarian at all: Europe's approval of United States data transfers is being challenged, and Europe's own privacy board asked the Commission on 31 July 2026 to re-examine it.High confidence
Hardest industry wall: Online gaming — Закон за хазарта

The eight framework questions answered for each selected country
Question	SpainChecked 18 August 2026	BulgariaChecked 18 August 2026
The three ratings	Depends on your industry Work: High Enforcement: Aggressive	Depends on your industry Work: Medium Enforcement: Active
In one paragraph	Spain follows the normal European rule: personal data may leave the country once you have the right paperwork in place. But four named categories of data held by the Spanish state must physically stay inside the European Union, and may only travel further to a country Europe has officially approved. Spain's privacy regulator is one of the busiest in the world.	Bulgaria is an ordinary European Union country for data. Personal data can leave, as long as you use one of the standard European transfer tools. There is no general rule forcing data to stay in Bulgaria. But online gambling is a hard exception: a control server must physically sit on Bulgarian soil. Bulgaria switched to the euro on 1 January 2026, so all fines are now in euro.
The catch	The relaxed headline stops being true the moment you touch the electoral roll, town-hall population registers, Spanish tax records or data about users of the Spanish national health service. For those four things a standard European transfer contract is not enough and never will be — the law allows only officially approved destinations. Online gambling, telecoms and any system sold to the Spanish public sector carry their own separate rules.	The relaxed headline stops being true in two places. First, online gambling: an operator licensed in Bulgaria must keep a control local server on Bulgarian territory and stream live game data to the tax authority's server. Second, telecoms: operators must build and pay for interception equipment wired into two Bulgarian state agencies, which cannot be run from abroad. Mapping and aerial survey work also needs clearance from five Bulgarian ministries and agencies before you may even collect the data.
Does this apply to me?	Yes. A company with no office in Spain is still caught if it offers goods or services to people in Spain or watches what they do online. There is no size or revenue threshold to hide under. If you have no base anywhere in Europe you must appoint a written representative inside Europe, and Spain's regulator will happily deal with that representative instead of you.High confidence	Yes, it can reach you with no office in Bulgaria. The European Union's privacy rulebook applies to anyone who offers goods or services to people in Europe or watches what they do online. Bulgaria's own Personal Data Protection Act sits on top of that and adds extra local duties. There is no revenue or headcount threshold, and no Bulgaria-specific representative: the European-wide requirement to name a representative in Europe is the only one, and it can be in any European country.High confidence
Can the data leave the country?	For most businesses, yes, with paperwork — the ordinary European rules apply and nothing in Spanish law says data must sit on Spanish soil. The exception is sharp. If the data is the electoral roll, a town-hall population register, Spanish tax records, or information about users of the Spanish national health service, the computers holding it must be inside the European Union, and that data may only go outside Europe to a country Europe has officially approved. A standard European transfer contract does not work for those four things.High confidence	In general, yes. Bulgaria has no law telling ordinary businesses to keep personal data inside the country. Data moves freely to the rest of Europe, to Switzerland, and to countries Europe has approved; anywhere else needs a standard contract or a similar tool. Two industries break that pattern. Online gambling operators must keep a control server physically in Bulgaria. Telecoms operators must build interception equipment that plugs into Bulgarian state agencies, which cannot sit abroad.High confidence
What do I have to do to send it abroad?	The model is an approved-list one, run at European level, not by Spain. You may send data outside Europe if the destination country is on Europe's approved list, or if you sign Europe's standard contract, or if your corporate group has approved internal rules. The list is real and populated. Spain adds one twist: if you want to use a home-made contract instead of the standard one, you must get written permission from the Spanish regulator first.High confidence	Bulgaria uses Europe's system, not its own. There is no Bulgarian list of banned countries and no Bulgarian permit to apply for. If the destination is inside Europe, the wider European Economic Area or Switzerland, nothing extra is needed. Otherwise you need either an official European approval of that country, or the standard European contract, or approved group-wide rules. One Bulgarian twist: Bulgarian law explicitly puts Switzerland on the same footing as a European Union country.High confidence
Who enforces this — and are they actually working?	The Spanish Data Protection Agency, and it is very much awake. Its public decision database held 46,925 decisions when we checked on 18 August 2026, with rulings signed as recently as 12 August 2026. Three regional authorities also enforce, covering public bodies in Catalonia, the Basque Country and Andalusia. Spain's artificial intelligence supervisor is now operating too and met the privacy agency in July 2026 to divide up the work.High confidence	The Commission for Personal Data Protection is the main regulator. It is real, staffed and it does issue formal decisions, including ones published across Europe. But it is not a heavy hitter. In a Europe-wide check on deletion rights reported in February 2026, it contacted twenty-three organisations, opened no formal investigations, imposed no penalties, and said it did not plan to. A separate inspectorate polices the courts and prosecutors. Cybersecurity has its own separate regulators.Medium confidence
How long must I keep it, and when must I delete it?	Both directions, and they collide. The longest floor is money laundering records: ten years, and the same law then orders you to destroy them. Business books run six years, clinical records at least five years from the end of each course of treatment, phone and internet connection records twelve months, and the taxman can come back four years. In the other direction Spain does something unusual: when someone asks you to delete their data you must not actually delete it, you must lock it away.High confidence	Bulgaria has strong minimum-keeping rules and a few sharp delete-by rules. You must keep payroll records for fifty years, accounting books and financial statements for ten years, and other accounting papers for three years. Telecoms firms keep connection records for six months. Going the other way, job applicants' data must be deleted within six months unless they agree otherwise, and data you were given with no legal basis must be returned or destroyed within one month.High confidence
What happens when something goes wrong?	Count three clocks, not one. Everyone has 72 hours to tell the privacy regulator about a personal data breach. Phone and internet providers have only 24 hours under a separate European rule. And if you run something the state treats as an essential service, the cyber clock says report immediately, then send an update within 24 to 48 hours if the incident is critical, or 72 hours if it is very serious, with a final report 20 or 40 days later.High confidence	There are at least three clocks and they do not agree. A personal data breach must reach the privacy regulator within seventy-two hours. Under the cybersecurity law rewritten in February 2026, an early warning must reach the response team within twenty-four hours and a fuller report within seventy-two hours. Trust service providers get twenty-four hours for that fuller report. Financial firms answer to the separate European financial-resilience rules on top.High confidence
What's the trap?	Five things that ruin weekends. One: a child can consent at fourteen in Spain, not sixteen, so your global age gate is probably wrong here. Two: 'delete my data' legally means 'lock my data away', so a hard-delete pipeline breaks the law. Three: Spain forces far more organisations to appoint a data protection officer than Europe does, including every school, university, bank, insurer, energy supplier and online gambling operator. Four: misusing someone's personal records is a crime punishable by prison, and companies themselves can be prosecuted. Five: telecoms operators can be ordered to hand over the encryption method they use.High confidence	Five things bite people in Bulgaria. You may not photocopy someone's identity card, driving licence or residence permit unless a law lets you. Children need a parent's consent up to age fourteen, not sixteen. Job applicant files must go within six months. Your accounting software must be able to output in Bulgarian. And one clause of the privacy law was struck down by the Constitutional Court in 2019 but is still printed in the statute.High confidence
What's about to change?	The biggest thing is what has not happened. Spain still has not passed the law that brings Europe's new cybersecurity rules into Spanish law, so the old 2018 regime is still what binds — expect that to change and to widen sharply who must report incidents. From 12 January 2027 no cloud provider may charge you to leave or to pull your data out. Watch three switches the government can flip with no consultation: taking over telecoms networks, ordering gambling systems into Spain, and demanding an operator's encryption method.Medium confidence	Two dated changes are already fixed. From 12 January 2027 every cloud provider must let customers move their data out for free. Bulgaria's new cybersecurity duties started on 13 February 2026 and enforcement is only now warming up. The biggest live risk is not Bulgarian at all: Europe's approval of United States data transfers is being challenged, and Europe's own privacy board asked the Commission on 31 July 2026 to re-examine it.High confidence
Hardest industry wall	None found.	Online gaming — Закон за хазарта